I'm a librarian who loves anime, manga, and reading a wide variety of genres.
So far, I wouldn't call this a paranormal romance. It's more fluffy urban fantasy.
I'm guessing I'm supposed to think the coven is fun and amusing, but instead they're annoying me. Would it kill them to give Lizzie a little info here and there? I don't blame her for not drinking the protection potion, since 1) her assumption that it contained roadkill didn't seem too off-base considering their usual spell components and 2) they didn't tell her that it was a protection potion.